Tuesday, 14 April 2015

Pre-emptive thoughts on Chris and Roz gaining voice

Last night I downloaded (all nice and legally and paid for, thank you) Big Finish's second box set of Virgin novel adaptations. I've already listened to The Well-Mannered War, which was delightful fun and seemed to adapt to audio better than the previous two Tom Baker/Gareth Roberts efforts. Next up, of course, is Damaged Goods, which has a lot going for it (or against it) in the expectations stakes.

Now, Damaged Goods is one of those New Adventures I've never read. I drifted out of the books towards the end and regret it immeasurably today since they were very good books and are now the devil to get ahold of now. Anyway, I never read it so I'm coming to this fresh. What I do know, however, is its the first published Doctor Who story by Russell T. Davies, future showrunner and series' resurrection mastermind; its one of the late-era New Adventures, from the time when the license had already been cancelled and the series put out some of its most challenging material; most of all, though, this marks the first time Roz Forrester and Chris Cwej (its pronounced “Kwedge”, apparently) have been portrayed by actors.

It'll be funny to hear actors playing these characters after nearly twenty years of defining them by voices dredged up from my imagination. I wonder if I'll like them enough to “recast” the characters as these actors when I read the books. To be honest, I can't remember how I imagined Bernice Summerfield's voice before I heard Lisa Bowerman play her. Bowerman's performance was just too pitch perfect that its her voice I hear when I re-read those books.

It'll also be interesting to see Chris and Roz as the Seventh Doctor's sole companions, the book being set after Bernice left the TARDIS. Again, because of how I drifted out of reading the books the Seventh Doctor, Chris and Roz crew isn't one I'm very familiar with. In fact, I think the only books I've read from that era are Return Of The Living Dad (which features Bernice anyway) and The Death Of Art (which shuffled Chris off on his own story) so I have practically zero experience of this crew.

Just a thought, or five. 

Monday, 13 April 2015

One week hobby challenge, one day later

Its not going too badly, I might actually finish the Glade Lord tonight. What's better is that as well as getting quite a way into painting the Glade Lord I've finished up three other models (a couple of Gretchin and my female Guardsman proof of concept model) and got some layers on a few others. All the time, though, I've been making steady progress on the Glade Lord because that's what I want to get done in a generous time limit.

I think I might have finally found a decent motivational method.

The Glade Lord is also really enjoyable to paint. Its deceptively simple, I got the base colours and inks done in an afternoon. It has a lot of large, block areas and it all divides up nicely into clearly defined areas. Plus the way I'm doing the armour is dead easy: Balthasar Gold followed by Sycoraz Bronze and done, maybe a little Runefang highlight. 

Sunday, 12 April 2015

One Week Hobby Challenge: model selection

As a spur to get some momentum behind my painting I've determined to start and finish a model within the week. funnily enough, even the process of choosing a model, one that will give me maximum enjoyment in painting, has been quite fun.
The photo even came out well, now I just have to work out how that happened.
Its going to be the Wood Elves Glade Lord with Great Weapon, a lovely sculpt that's aged very well. Its nearly ten years old, it made the transition to resin very well with all that lovely detail on the armour and the quiver. It also has a lot of different materials to paint: armour, cloth, wood, the steel blade, the hair, so I'll be getting a lot of practical experience for the rest of the army.

Time for a shout-out because I'm not painting this completely on my own initiative: I'll be making a lot of reference to this painting tutorial by The Apathetic Fish on Youtube. He does great painting tutorials and I recommend them to anyone painting GW miniatures. Not only does he explain himself well, working stage-by-stage so you can follow along, but he generally uses GW paints. I realise there are probably better paints out there but the GW Citadel range is what I have easy access to and I imagine that's true for a lot of hobbyists. Its useful not to have to stare at the screen trying to work out what GW paint corresponds to the colour on screen and hoping it'll layer the same way (which it usually won't because chemistry). This way is just more useful to me.

So I have my model, I have a list of techniques I want to test out, I have seven days to do it and once its done I'll have either 151 or 79 points of my Wood Elves finished (can't decide whether this will be a Glade Lord or Captain).

Begin!

Saturday, 11 April 2015

Daredevil season 1 episode 1: Into the Ring

(SPOILERS purely for the first episode)

Work commitments mean that I've only watched the first of the thirteen episodes, so let's talk episode one. Now, I actually quite liked the old movie, mess though it was. Still, it has to be said this was better in every damn way. Even as I write this up I'm resisting the urge to just binge-watch the whole lot tonight instead of savouring it.

For a start, the series has a rock solid cast. Charlie Cox puts in a great performance as Matt Murdoch, one that really sells the physicality of the role. There's a scene where he's setting up his desk at the new offices of Nelson & Murdoch, he's not even the main focus of the camera but he plays the hell out of setting up his desk “blind”: his head doesn't move to follow anything, not even slightly, its all done by touch and there are numerous moments like that throughout the episode. Its all very intelligently directed. There are also plenty of moments when characters screw up in their interactions with Matt: nodding instead of saying yes, a realtor makes a comment about the view and feels embarrassed by it, again all handled intelligently and not used as a subtext to make characters unsympathetic.

The main cast is rounded out by Eldon Henson as Foggy Nelson and Jessica Ann Woll as Nelson & Murdoch's first client Karen Page. I love that they've gone with Karen Page instead of jumping in with Elektra as the love interest. I like Elektra fine enough but there's something about throwing in the emotionally complicated friend/enemy ninja right off the bat that kind of harms the worldbuilding. Introducing the secretary character as the first client, however, works to set up the lawyer world just as well as the superhero/vigilante world.

Best of the three so far, though, is Eldon Henson as Foggy: chummy, charming and just a little bit sleazy. Henson gets many of the episode's best lines, including a joke straight out of Bendis' run about Matt's ability to home in on beautiful yet screwed up women. I'm sorry to see the series going for the “Foggy doesn't know about Matt's powers” version of the character but there's more than enough chance for that to change.

But what I liked the most about this? That as dark as it gets (with human trafficking being a subplot) and as violent as it gets (a man has his eye poked out in a fight) its amazing how little influence Frank Miller has on the whole thing. Yes, Matt is at this stage wearing the cod-ninja costume Miller wrote into the origin but that's about it.

For the Marvel nerds out there (of which I am, obviously, one) there are some nice nods here and there, not only to the films but to the comics. My favourite was an old boxing poster advertising a Crusher Creel match. Well, that and the fact the main fallout of the Battle Of New York as far as Matt and Foggy's world is concerned is a sudden drop in property prices that allows them to invest in their own offices.

I am very much looking forward to this and the other Netflix Originals coming from Marvel. 

Friday, 10 April 2015

Getting Back On The Hobby Horse


I was surprised, finding my hobby diary, that I haven't actually finished a model in nearly a year. Its the usual story: I start something, I get distracted, life gets in the way and so on. I really, really need to get back on this horse, especially as I've just acquired a load of Wood Elves models from a friend who's simply lost interest in the army (in exchange for some Dwarfs I want rid of for essentially the same reason).

So this coming week I have the simplest possible hobby goal: start painting a model, any model, and finish it. Not sure what, doesn't matter what, though out-of-production female Wood Elf Lord Matt gave me does rather appeal (though she'll need acid bathing to get rid of a truly hideous green basecoat). Or the Harlequin Solitaire I impulse bought when it came out.

Let's see if I can manage just this: one model in one week. 

Thursday, 9 April 2015

The Bat Man Of Shanghai

This thing is a year old but I only saw it because Hannah J. Rothman posted it on her tumblr. Its a Batman alternate universe set in 1930s Shanghai, the first chapter is here (if the link tops working just write “Batman Shanghai” in the search) and its has a playlist that'll show you the lot. It was an official DC production and, good grief, I want more.

I love the art style, sketchy as it may be. I love the Catwoman redesign that dumps almost all the traditional and modern aspects of her appearance yet creating something totally fitting for her and totally fitting for the setting.

Its a year later and I doubt we'll see anything come of this but it strikes me as a genuinely interesting concept that could do with more exploration. I wonder how other characters like Robin or Oracle would appear and act in this world, I wonder what theatrical tradition could be plundered for a Shanghai Harley Quinn and what Bruce's civilian life (hell, even his name) is in this world.

Or maybe I'm just pre-emptively jonesing for the Asian aesthetic since I'm going to run out of Legend Of Korra sometime soon. 

Wednesday, 8 April 2015

Bleach: first-ish impressions

Bleach: never read it, never watched it, the whole thing just sort of passed me by. Most long form manga and anime do that, to be honest just because of the sheer weight of effort getting caught up on it takes. However, when I saw the first fifteen or so volumes in a bundle at Oxfam for £10 I thought “Why not?”.

I'll be honest, the premise really grabbed me. There's a guy called Ichigo who can see ghosts and a spirit called Rukia whose job it is to slay Hollows, a kind of soul-eating demon that ghosts turn into if they stick around in this world for too long. Rukia should be invisible but Ichigo can see her and gets involved in her fight. Things go waaaaaaay south and he somehow absorbs her powers and she's reduced to mortality. They have an interesting relationship based mainly on annoying one another, though Rukia gets most of the truly great trolling moments.

And together they solve crimes!

Okay, no, seriously, she becomes his mentor because someone needs to fight the Hollows while she's basically up on bricks. This is all set against a steadily growing cast of the city's supernatural residents and Ichigo's schoolmates, not always separately.

It moved on at a fair clip, as well, at least for the first six books. Arcs were short and to the point, introducing new characters and bits of lore that flesh out the world. Funny jokes, too.

Then volume seven happened, starting a storyline that's still going strong in volume fourteen with no end in sight. Well, that's not quite true: there was an end in sight in volume fourteen but then a bigger bad guy appeared and the heroes had to retreat to get stronger to come back and fight that one, a process that has been repeated a time or two in the arc so far.

The thing is that I was looking forward to this arc when the premise became clear: Rukia's superiors come to take her home, none too pleased her powers were taken from her and Ichigo goes through hell to get her back (at times, literally). I was really looking forward to seeing how the “Soul Society” functioned but what I got was an almost stereotypical succession of manga fight scenes. Its not without its pleasure but its been going on for hundreds of pages now. True, it hasn't reached the level of gibbering stasis I've seen some mangas devolve into (oh, you wanted to know how that revelation will affect the heroes? Well, here's ten chapters of bloody Sasuke and his B-list goon squad doing sod all!) but I'm worried it might be getting there.

Still, time (and, hopefully, the remaining couple of volumes I bought), will tell. 

Tuesday, 7 April 2015

Random models for specific purposes


I'm a pretty utilitarian hobbyist in many ways. Whilst I have a lot of projects on the go at any one time (oh, you noticed?) they all tend to be with the stated intention, if not actually the result of, having a playable army. Recently, though, I've been getting models for another reason: learning.

I've started buying odd, one-off models to test out techniques and polish a certain skill. For instance, I really need to get better at painting smooth skin tones. My old “drybrush the fuck out Bugman's Glow with Cadian Flesh” method is good for human soldiers who look okay a bit sunburnt but for High Elves it isn't quite so convincing. An elf, especially a High Ekf in his fine white robes, should not look sunburnt.
Image from Games Workshop webstore, I ain't that good.

So I ordered a Wood Elves Shadowdancer because, as you can see, she's not wearing much so I'll have plenty of chance to practice. True, she won't be much use afterwards but the model will look pretty and if I ever do a Wood Elves army that's 160 points of character allowance taken care of.

On a similar note, if I don't decide to pursue the Mechanicus as an army (we'll see when the Codex arrives) then at least the Skitarii will have given me plenty of experience highlighting metal, another thing I want to practice.

The thing about being utilitarian, you see, is you can justify just about anything. 

Monday, 6 April 2015

Adeptus Mechanicus Skitarii Rangers build review


Since, for some reason, my photos (which almost came out well, too) won't render when I preview this post I'll just list what I built for sake of clarity: five Skitarii Rangers with galvanic rifles, one with galvanic rifle and omnispex, one with plasma caliver, one with arc rifle, one with transuranic arquebus and an Alpha with arc pistol and taser goad.

Ease of Build
Okay, bit of an ancillary rant here but I need this for context: I bloody hate the bolters in the new Space Marine kits, they are a dryfitting nightmare to build. Who even though that making the three-part assemble less stable and harder to dryfit was a good idea?

Anyway, this kit does not do that with its guns, not on any of the builds: each gun assembly has two components: a large piece made of the gun and the whole right arm of the model and the second is the left arm that completes the assembly. Most of the guns are mono-pose but that's good as the reason for this is a groove under the armpit of the right arm that slots over one of the pipes on the side of the torso. It means you'll always get the right pose for the other arm to slot into without having to dry fit and practice. There were a couple of galvanic rifles without this feature and its absent on the plasma culiver as well but those guns are more forgivingly posed so that wasn't a problem.

The locating groove is part of the transuranic arquebus which I am immensely grateful for as I was worried the stand (which is a separate piece) would end up crooked if I didn't pose the arquebus perfectly straight.

Ease of Conversion
Since my first though was Renegades & Heretics conversions on these puppies I did look closely at how these could be converted. To be honest, if you want to swap the torsos out for something else, obvious option being the R&H conversion kits from Forge World, you're wasting some of the most characterful parts in the kit and I'm not sure the arms will fit them.

Head and weapon swaps shouldn't be too hard and I wonder if some sort of feral servitor or techno-barbarian close combat model could be made like that.

Take this as you will: I did some dryfitting and the spare head (the Vanguard variant) fit near perfectly on a Tempestus Scion and with a little cutting down of the ball join they don't look too out of scale with a Cadian Guardsman.

Spare Parts
I have ten Vanguard heads and a few champion head variants plus various champion weapons options which will come in useful if there are HQ options in the Codex (or, touch wood, the full-size Adeptus Mechanicus Codex I anticipate will come after given the range branding). There are also the spare galvanic rifle and radium carbine assemblies though I'm not sure how useful they'll be unless they turn out to fit Guardsmen. There's also one radium carbine and one galvanic rifle just on their own, no hands attached, which might be useful for diorama or vehicle decoration. 

Sunday, 5 April 2015

Army Project: Adeptus Mechanicus

When I pre-ordered the Skitarii box set I was sort of planning on using them for conversions, make up some Dark Mechanicus for my Renegades & Heretics army. The thing is, though, that this is an opportunity that comes up very rarely in this hobby: the chance to collect a genuinely new faction.

Yes, we've had Harlequins and Khorne Daemonkin already this year but both those factions existed in some form before now: Harlequins as a unit option and Daemonkin is basically a bunch of special rules for existing Chaos Marine/Chaos Daemon allied armies. Mechanicus have not been a playable faction since the first edition which was so long ago and such a different gaming environment that it doesn't really count as the same thing. They're only the second new faction since I started playing these games (the other was Ogre Kingdoms in 2005) and I missed the boat on that one.

So instead of converting them I'm tempted to just make an Adeptus Mechanicus army. It'll be interesting because I'll be at no more of a disadvantage than anyone else buying the army since its brand new; I don't have any old models or ideas for the army so I can come to the background fresh; and every model is new to me so they're fresh and interesting by default.
All that said I don't know if I'll use Sicarian Infiltrators since they look like... well...
... yeah, him. I'd be tempted and I can't bring myself to paint something like that. The Ruststalker variant looks cool, though. 

Saturday, 4 April 2015

Fit for legacy: Big Finish Doctor Who novel adaptations


I'm a bit torn on Big Finish doing adaptations of the New Adventures novels. On the one hand the two they've done so far were good, The Highest Science especially, and its cool that a new generation of fans are being given a chance to experience these hard-to-find stories. On the other hand I'd really like it to be possible for a wide audience to experience these stories as novels, the way they were originally intended, especially as there are so many that can't be adapted because necessary cast members have passed on (Blood Heat, Happy Endings, The Dying Days and Eternity Weeps to name a few). 
Theatre of War
I know its a pretty minor aspect of the novel but I wonder if they'll do something with the Benny and Brax stuff at the beginning that reflects their future together. Aside from that I really don't remember much about this one but its by Justin Richards who was one of the more dependable wilderness years authors.
All-Consuming Fire
I've only listened to a couple of Big Finish's Sherlock Holmes range but I am interested to see how Nicholas Briggs' Holmes works out in this one. Its a cool genre mash-up, though I hope some of the more problematic aspects (there's a hell of a hash-up in the book about the differences between Islam and Hinduism) get ironed out in editing.

Actually, what interests me about these first two choices are they involve New Ace, the older space marine version of the character which Big Finish have historically had a lot of trouble with. This isn't unexpected, after all his version of the character developed without the actress' involvement. That said, the two previous attempts at New Ace on audio were tribute acts and these are the original source material. Not that the source material was always that good where New Ace was concerned.
Nightshade
I have read Nightshade but I don't really remember it that well. I remember enjoying it but that's about it. Its a pre-Bernice book, an interesting choice because that was a sort of developmental phase where the series hadn't really settled on a tone. Not necessarily a bad choice, mind you, I could do without every adaptation being one of the Dark Doctor type stories.
Original Sin
Probably the one I'm looking forward to the most: Chris and Roz's origin story featuring the return of one of the TV series' most interesting villains (no spoilers, though they will have to re-cast). One of the Virgin line's biggest selling points was its detailed and consistent future history and I'm looking forward to seeing how the 30th century mega-cities come across on audio.
untitled fifth novel
Okay, maybe its going to be something completely out of left field since it isn't listed as starring Sylvester McCoy (Vampire Science? A man can dream) but let's assume its a New Adventure for the time being.

Its three discs so either its a long novel or one they didn't want to cut too much. For my money I'd guess either Human Nature (absolutely iconic); The Also People (long and complicated and awesome) or So Vile A Sin (stupidly hard to find and ridiculously expensive if you do). That said, I'm always suspicious when a company asks for pre-order money without revealing the title, so it might be something like bloody Parasite or Falls The Shadow.

Could be Deceit, I suppose, if they want to have another crack at New Ace then doing her origin story might help give Sophie Aldred some context for her performance. 

Friday, 3 April 2015

Is the Prime Directive no more?


I've been thinking about it and if there's one thing I can get behind with the soulless action movies currently lurching around in the flayed skin of Star Trek its that the writers seemed to have largely dumped the Prime Directive.

Now, as a general case the PD is very high-minded and enlightened in a 1960s end-of-empires sort of way. Its there to show that humanity has learnt its lessons about just blithely destroying indigenous cultures and that just interacting with a new culture comes with moral responsibility.

However, looking back at it the PD was usually used as a cop-out so writers could avoid the consequences of confronting actual moral obscenities. If that seems like a harsh judgement on my part then look at any Voyager episode featuring the Vidiians. Yes, they're murderous organ-harvesters but but only because of the chronic flesh-eating disease they suffer from and yet Captain Janeway continuously refuses to offer them medical or humanitarian aid. The disease, by the way, turns out to be curable (there's a throwaway line about it in Think Tank). Its even worse in the early seasons of The Next Generation which all too often devolved into Picard and his crew very high-mindedly doing nothing and congratulate themselves on how moral they are as material suffering continues off-screen.

Now, the Prime Directive does feature in Into Darkness but only in its First Contact form (the episode, not the movie): you don't let pre-warp cultures know there's more out there because they have to make those discoveries on their own. The version where you just fly past atrocities, however, seems to have been left behind and I can't say I'm disappointed.

Now all we need is a movie that actually has something to say about... anything, really. Neither Star Trek (2009) or Into Darkness had much political or philosophical content to play with. 

Thursday, 2 April 2015

The Eight Doctors with a side order of objectivity ranting

From the TARDIS data bank
The Eight Doctors by Terrance Dicks: opening novel of the original Eighth Doctor novels; published June 1997; it follows on from the events of the 1996 TV Movie with an amnesiac Eighth Doctor meeting his previous selves in sequence to get his memories back; the novel also introduces new companion Samantha “Sam” Jones.

Canon fodder
The bulk of the novel takes place during or immediately after televised stories, we'll get to the full list later. Dicks actively de-canonises the New Adventures novels from at least First Frontier onwards, using the Anthony Ainley Master in a section set immediately prior to the TV Movie, which also contradicts the ending of Lungbarrow in the process.
In the “everything is canon in the Doctor Who universe except the Noddy series (unless the Doctor was lying)” stakes: a Roman officer in the War Games section of the novel refers to Lurcio's tavern in Rome so Up Pompeii and Further Up Pompeii canonically take place in the Doctor Who universe.

Review
There's this pernicious belief on the internet right now that “objective review” is something that can exist and I provide no better counter-argument than The Eight Doctors by Terrance Dicks. This book is an infamous failure, a book so completely unsuited to launching the series it does that its amazing any editor would allow it to. However, using the only objective metrics I can think of I'd actually have to recommend it:

You see, it isn't as if this book is unreadable, far from it. I breezed through its 280 pages in two sittings, which for me is lightning speed. Terrance Dicks, elder statesman of Doctor Who and its most prolific noveliser, is pretty much incapable of writing bad prose. The characters he lifts from the TV show all act more or less as they did on television, voices and mannerisms captured near perfectly. The structure of the novel even gives the mythical new audience it was supposedly designed for a halfway decent primer on the high points of the television series. This is as close to an objective analysis of the novel I can produce and even then, let it be noted by the delusional people who think this is a good idea, it is still moderated through my personal and (all together now) subjective experience.

And once we get past this tissue-thin veneer of objectivity we are left with a very readable book that is mediocre on its own merits but where context screws it over into being outright the worst thing the BBC could have published in that precise moment. The root of the problem is that what was required, what was requested and what Terrance Dicks would inevitably produce were wildly at odds.

There are a lot of ways to go with the sentence “The problem with the TV Movie was...” but the one that concerns us here is the fact there's almost nothing in the movie telling us what the new Doctor is like. Between getting Sylvester McCoy in to film a regeneration and over-egging the post-regenerative amnesia we never get to see what the Eighth Doctor acts like when its business as usual. Unfortunately, one of Dicks' oft-stated opinions is that the Doctor is always fundamentally the same guy and only surface details change. Add in an editor who was nowhere near as big on co-ordinating authors as Peter Darvill-Evans and Rebecca Levene were at Virgin and the idea of strongly establishing an identity for the Eighth Doctor falls at the first hurdle.

Then there's the idea that a year after the TV Movie there was going to be a new audience largely unfamiliar with Doctor Who chomping at the bit to read this thing. I'm all for optimism but you can go too far in your blue sky thinking. However, if you're genuinely working under this assumption then Terrance Dicks would definitely seem like the way to go: he's reliable; his work is of consistent quality; he's written for just about every Doctor in one form or another; he knows the series' history because he was a huge part of it himself; and therein lies the rub...

What was needed was a bold statement about who the Eighth Doctor is and why the reader should be dropping £4.99 a month on these books, especially considering they replaced the beloved New Adventures line. What was delivered was a nostalgia tour through the history of Doctor Who as Dicks has an amnesiac Eighth Doctor meeting up with his previous selves one by one. Dicks was already King Of The Sequels at this point in his career but here he goes into overdrive giving us a series of interludes and epilogues to 1000,000 BC, The War Games, The Sea Devils, State Of Decay, The Five Doctors and The Trial Of A Time Lord before stopping off to give us a prologue to the TV Movie. What's more, the Sea Devils section is also a sequel to The Daemons; the Trial Of A Time Lord section is a sequel to The Five Doctors and a couple of characters and concepts from The Deadly Assassin turn up for good measure. Obviously, Dicks immensely favours expanding his own previous work here with every section from the Second to the Fifth Doctors being based on a story he either wrote or edited and the Sixth Doctor section being a sequel to one of his stories as well. Maybe its ego, maybe its just pragmatism, but at the end of the day it means the lion's share of Doctor Who is being presented through the lens of one man's body of work.

And none of it says much about any of it. There are few judgements on the ethics or aesthetic of those previous eras other than the fact that the First Doctor was wrong to try and kill someone and Dicks' being oddly down on the Seventh Doctor to the point of writing him as borderline suicidal. There's no comment on how these choices relate to the greater whole of the series just “Here's some nostalgia: enjoy!”. Given the fact that the Eighth Doctor is even more of a blank slate here than he was on television there's no point of comparison between then and now because there's nothing to compare the past with.

All of this is secondary, though, to the fact this does nothing to launch the Eighth Doctor as a concept. Dicks plainly dislikes the TV Movie, which is amazing given how neutral a narrator he was in his novelisations, describing it as “a weird, fantastic adventure, full of improbable, illogical events”, a critical mauling not at all softened by apparently being the Doctor's own thoughts on the matter. Still, it would have been a start to giving this Doctor some sense of character but then he stumbles into a trap a Master left behind and the amnesia sets in. Worse, the book spends chapters at a time away from the Eighth Doctor, setting up the adventures he's going to visit rather than having him jump straight into them.

And how on Earth did it feel like a good idea to take the end of The Trial Of A Time Lord and make it even more complicated by introducing an alternate timeline into the mix?

This review is in danger of turning into a rant but, ultimately, The Eight Doctors is more offensive due to circumstance than in what it actually is. If it had come later in the run or as an anthology separate from the ongoing series it would, as I say, be mediocre rather than facepalmingly frustrating. True, Dicks' unfortunate class politics show up good and proper in the Sixth Doctor section as we finally meet the Shobogans alluded to in The Deadly Assassin. They were originally a throwaway line of the sort Robert Holmes used to flesh out worlds and blatantly never expected to see expanded (see also, as this novel and many other Dicks-penned works do, the Celestial Intervention Agency). Here Dicks presents them as hard-drinking, violent savages living underneath the Gallifreyan Capitol who speak with a slightly stilted, caveman-esque vocabulary. He even recycles the trick from The Monster Of Peladon (largely his own script) of giving these lower class characters harsh sounding names like Kagar and Marek.

What this series needed was a strong beginning but what it got was nostalgia: the thing that ultimately doomed the TV series and crippled the TV Movie with the weight of having to please the fans with continuity porn and a pointless, time-wasting regeneration. Sadly, this set something of a tone as the Eighth Doctor novels would have a very shaky relationship with the series' past over the years.

In the end, reading this book I was confronted by one question, a question I really think should have been asked more often by everyone involved in writing this book:

What's the point of this novel?

Wednesday, 1 April 2015

What Jeremy Clarkson should do next

Seriously, I did not pick this picture to make any king of point,
this was the #1 result on Google Image Search
So I had this great idea for Jeremy Clarkson's next career move now the BBC have booted him over the whole assaulting his producer thing. Obviously, he's just going to end up on another channel bringing in millions of viewers for another car show but there's another branch of entertainment he'd be perfect for.

Just look at the facts: he's pretty rough looking, casually racist, casually misogynist, casually homophobic, and he recently punched his boss.
Their Wrestlemania match was amazing, by the way, pure nerd pleasing spectacle.
Is this not the perfect set of qualifications for going into professional wrestling? 

Okay, with Clarkson it isn't an act but there have been any number of genuine dickbags in pro wrestling. I mean, he's obviously too old for the ring but he'd make a decent manager, maybe even make him general manager of one of the brands in a year or so's time. (I'm just getting back into wrestling now the WWE Network's online so I'm honestly not sure who the general managers are at this stage so in case he's still around I am not lobbying for Teddy Long to be replaced. Teddy Long is amazing, playa!.)

The highlight of it would, of course, be watching Clarkson and JBL trying to out-conservative each other at the announce table.

Just an idea. 

Monday, 30 March 2015

Rose, ten years on

(This was meant to post on the actual anniversary but for some reason all the posts I queued just didn't go up.)

Its funny to think that Doctor Who has been back for ten years now and not just in the “Bloody hell, I was twenty-one when this started” sense. I suppose its because I fell into this fandom in the early Nineties when the show was not only dead but a cultural joke remembered for its wobbly sets and wobblier acting (not entirely unfairly, mind). I watched repeats when they were on, bought the videos when the repeats stopped and eventually started reading the Virgin-era novels which I was the perfect age to appreciate (i.e. 12, so the sex and violence really did seem “mature” to me). There were the two Pertwee-starring radio dramas but that petered off into nothing because of awfulness. Doctor Who was great but, sadly, it was probably never coming back to TV.

Then 1996 happened and it definitely wasn't coming back after that.

Ah yes, the TV Movie. I didn't read Doctor Who Magazine then so I missed all the hype and only heard about it when the trailers started a few weeks before it aired. I watched it, taking in every second because my favourite thing in the world was back on TV where it belonged and I'm not ashamed to admit I loved it then. The excitement of it drew me in and it wasn't until later that I started picking holes in it. With adult eyes I can see why it didn't go to series, which is to say the script was terrible and it did an amazingly poor job of introducing the series' core concepts to new and casual viewers.

Then, just to add insult to injury the BBC used it as pretext to snatch the novel license away from Virgin.

It wasn't the last false dawn, either. There was a rumoured cartoon series a few years later that came to nothing, the Death Comes To Time webcast with its baffling desire to be Star Wars which was followed by Scream Of The Shalka which even gave us a “Ninth Doctor” in Richard E. Grant. None of them were very good, none of them came to anything. The BBC novels dribbled on and Big Finish was producing original audio dramas so it seemed Doctor Who had found its retirement home.

Then 2005 happened and it was really, genuinely back.

I watched Rose almost grudgingly, I must admit. I was at university by then and whilst the mockery of my love for this old, creaky dinosaur of a TV show had moved from malicious schoolyard stuff to the fond ribbing of fellow geeks I knew if this was bad I was going to hear all about it in the bar on Sunday.

So imagine my surprise when it wasn't bad. In fact, it was good. Suddenly, all the false dawns had gained a purpose other than wasting my time because Russell T. Davies had obviously watched them himself and noted down all their mistakes. In Rose, time and money weren't wasted on a fan pleasing regeneration, instead the issue was dealt with in a throwaway line; there was no attempt to radically retool the concept of the Doctor to modern tastes other than dumping the ostentatious Edwardian clothing for actual clothes; the new Doctor had a solid personality from the start instead of just writing a generic Doctor and hoping for the best; and the companion...

I'm not going to mince words, Billie Piper was great. I admit she was the one part of the experiment I worried about, mainly because I was at that age when you really start regretting the musical choices of your adolescence, but she blew it out of the park in that episode and most of the others she was in. If nothing else, I can say she absolutely earned being the only returning companion in the 50th anniversary special.

Yes, the plot of the episode itself is thin, the anti-plastic an absolute cop-out MacGuffin but that was never the point of the exercise. The point was to have a light adventure plot for Ecclestone and Piper to have chemistry against. The whole episode is designed to give its two leads big moments, both together and separately, that people will remember and want to see more of. Using the Autons (already veteran villains of Doctor Who relaunches past) was a stroke of genius: silent, faceless and not liable to get in the way of the heroes getting over with the audience.

I'm not an unabashed Davies fanboy (or an unabashed Moffatt fanboy either, for that matter) but having watched, read and listened to so many awful to mediocre attempts to resurrect the series I was so grateful to see lessons had been learned. Yes, like the TV Movie I was picking holes in it by the next morning but it turned out that light plots were a hallmark of Davies' approach to opening a season, getting people's attention with the Doctor and companion's chemistry rather than flashy plot.

And, you know what? As odd as it was at the time I do wish the DVD had an audio option to insert Graham Norton's unscheduled guest appearance, I feel that was an part integral of the experience. 

Friday, 27 March 2015

Anime: the old subs or dubs debate


It came up the other day that on the rare occasions I watch anime I tend to watch the Japanese dub with subtitles. Some people I didn't know thought this was pretentious on my part. There were a lot of people there and the conversation moved on so I'm just going to put my defence here and be done with it.

You see, it really isn't just me being pretentious. What it is, is me finding the Godawful, am-dram wannabes most US channels employ to record dubs painful to listen to. Over... oh, it must be nearly as decade of on-off dipping into various anime I can name offhand four series with good English dubs.

(Soul Eater, Cowboy Bebop, Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex and Full Metal Alchemist, in case you were wondering.)

I understand why dubs tend to be bad: imported TV is cheap TV that exists so the broadcaster doesn't have to spend too much making it so you're unlikely to get the sort of voice-acting that graces the likes of Korra or Archer. That's perfectly understandable but it doesn't make it any more pleasant to listen to. Especially if the character is a blonde woman because for some reason blondeness is too often represented by these voice actors by raising the voice several octaves higher than any living human woman actually speaks.

But, seriously though, the US voice cast for Soul Eater is spectacular. 

Wednesday, 25 March 2015

I don't usually comment on GW leaks, but...


… the fact the Skitarii Vanguard seem to be wearing Sabbat helms feels like salt in the wound. I mean, we're getting Skitarii, we're getting a unified Khorne Codex, we've already had Eldar Harlequins and Knight-class Titans (and I will call them “Knight-class Titans” until the day I die, damn it!) so the continued absence of Sisters of Battle really rankles.

Sisters. They're a cool idea. Nuns with guns. All I'm sayin'.

Still, I am very, very interested to see what GW does with Mechanicus as a faction in their own right. I don't for a second believe the Codex will include Forge World units. True, the odd Forge World Imperial Guard tank has made it in but I don't buy into them doing something as extensive as slotting the whole “Mechanicum” range into a new Codex. Could be wrong but I don't think Forge World's production and distribution are up to the task.

We'll see. 

Sunday, 22 March 2015

Female Imperial Guard test mini (grey)


(Crappy photos are crappy, I know, but this is just the build and hopefully you get enough of an idea of how it looks. Must get me one of these magical daylight bulbs people talk about because, good grief, do I not get good light in this place during any time of day I'm actually around.)
So the Heroic Scale Female Heads from Statuesque Miniatures turned up a couple of days ago and I quickly cobbled together a test mini using some spare Cadian parts.
The good: the head is very much in scale and the legs don't seem out of proportion as I feared because the big pockets on the side account for a measure of the bulk. I might have to rethink the Victoria Lamb order I was going to make for kilted legs if basic Cadian parts work this well.
The bad: the connector at the base of the neck is flat. The ironsighting pose you see here is because that's the only way the head attaches to the torso. I'm going to need to buy some modelling putty and build up the necks of the models to make pretty much any other pose. Not a huge problem but annoyingly time-consuming. I looked at the conversions I'd seen on line and, yes, green stuff necks.

Ah, well.

Still, the overall effect works and even my incredibly messy putty sculpting should be up to making necks (or at least not be to


o noticeable at a distance).

Saturday, 21 March 2015

Khorne Daemonkin pre-order thoughts

Looking back on it I have a mixture of fond nostalgia and head-scratching frustration for the old “3.5” version of Codex: Chaos Space Marines. I loved how that book worked even if how it worked was ridiculously twisted at times (seriously, some of the rules were hidden in the fiction sections). I loved how you got all sorts of perks for having an army exclusively dedicated to one Chaos God or wholly representing a single Legion. I loved that there were whole pages of god-specific wargear and vehicle upgrades.

So you can imagine that I'm reeeeeealy looking forward to Codex: Khorne Daemonkin because this is how I see Chaos armies: not as Chaos armies but as Khorne armies or Tzeentch armies and so on. I know I'm not alone among my generation of hobbyists that I could never get used to the “pantheonic” approach GW piloted with the first Chaos Daemon/Daemons Of Chaos release.

I've never really got used to how Daemon armies work. What I want is an army dedicated to a single god but the army is built to work best with the pantheonic approach. Plus, there just aren't enough units for a single god to stop me getting bored.

All this said it isn't the Khorne Daemonkin that I'm excited about. I'm hoping there are others in the works, specifically for Nurgle and Tzeentch Daemonkin warbands. I love the Death Guard and Thousand Sons background and models (I have a bunch of Forge World Death Guard in a draw ever ready for deployment) and I'd love to do warbands with those themes.

Plus, Renegades & Heretics should be Battle Brothers with the Daemonkin so there's even more variety and potential for fun conversions. 

Friday, 20 March 2015

Renegades & Heretics part 2: other HQ options

A quick note about Renegade Command Squads
Something I didn't mention about this unit in the Warlord post, because I'm an idiot who misses obvious things, is that unlike the Imperial Guard version you can add extra men to the Renegade Command Squad. The basic cost covers your Arch-Demagogue and four Disciples but you can add up to ten more Disciples. Renegades & Heretics are usually a bit more of horde than Guard so having a few extra meatshields around your Warlord is probably a good thing.

The Renegade Command Squad is the only actual unit in the HQ slots, the other options being individuals you buy in groups and split across the army.

Rogue Psyker Coven
One of the big problems I have with this list is that the basic psykers don't have access to Daemonology. In fact, they don't have access to Disciplines at all and instead generate a power from a D3 chart included in the army list. The powers aren't bad: there's a Strength 7 Blast, a Malediction and a Blessing but I really think a Chaos army should be able to have Daemonology without having to burn the Warlord on it.

On the other hand, they have two wounds and a natty little rule called The Daemon Unbound. The way this rule works is that when the Rogue Psyker takes a wound from Perils Of The Warp they become Possessed, gaining Weapon Skill and Strength 5, Rending and Feel No Pain (4+). Also on the plus side they're one of the few units in the army with stable Leadership: 8 for Psykers, 10 for Possessed.

They're by no means a bad choice and its fun to see them explode into monsters when something goes wrong but I would really, really have liked more ways to get Daemonology into the army.

Renegade Enforcers Cadre
Chaos Commissars, basically. Like the Psykers you buy them as a group but deploy them separately. Unlike the Psykers they can't be deployed independently (which would, admittedly, be pointless) and have to be assigned to a unit. They can only be assigned to Renegade Infantry Squads, Renegade Mutant Rabbles or Renegade Veterans, which is an oddly restrictive list.

Anyway, once attached they give the unit +1 Leadership (to the usual maximum of 10) once their Uncertain Worth has been determined. You also get a re-roll on failed Leadership tests after they pop a model of your choice from the unit. They can't be the Warlord but we've already established there's sod all point in having anyone other than the Arch-Demagogue be the Warlord.

Psykers or Enforcers?
Unlike their Guard equivalents both Psyker Covens and Enforcer Cadres do count as HQ choices on the Force Organisation Chart so you have to choose between them to remain Battle Forged (the Command Squad being compulsory).

I'm not quite sold on either as a superior choice but I think there are enough ways to compensate for Uncertain Worth that Psykers might be a better pick than Enforcers in most cases. I might not like how restricted their powers are but the D3 chart isn't terrible. 

Thursday, 19 March 2015

A personal, subjective view on the Batgirl Joker variant


The title of this post is meant to convey that this is what I feel about the whole business of DC soliciting and then pulling the Batgirl Joker variant cover. I'm not trying to make a definitive statement here, least of all because the artist, Rafael Albuquerque, wrote an open letter on the subject which I think deserves pre-eminence. Its a bit of non-apology but it does seem to represent genuine contrition, which is good because DC's own statement pretty much throws Albuquerque under a bus in lieu of admitting any fault on their part.

(That said, I can't say whether the theme of the piece was Albuquerque's or DC editorial's idea. After all, you say “Batgirl Joker variant” and the natural pitch is “Killing Joke tribute”, so who knows whose idea it was).
As to the cover itself? I think its a really good piece of art if divorced from context. Hell, even given its context I think its well-drawn. Its technically proficient and genuinely disturbing. I'm a strong believer that art is meant to provoke an emotional reaction and that reaction doesn't need to be positive to have worth. The problem, and I feel there really is a problem, comes from the context this image would have been published in.

As the cover to a horror comic or even to Gail Simone's run on Batgirl it might even have worked. Simone's Batgirl dwelt a lot on the trauma Barbara suffered as a result of The Killing Joke. Put this cover on one of the early Death Of The Family tie-in issues and it would work perfectly, an expression of Barbara's lingering unresolved issues, especially given the presence of the gun (one of Simone's earliest issues has Barbara freeze when a gun is pointed at her).

The actual context of this piece, however, would have been an issue of the Stewart/Fletcher run which DC has heavily marketed to the female young adult audience. Its pretty much the prototype for the way DC intends to diversify its content and audience coming out of Convergence. This is the comic DC is pushing to young women to show them they have a place within the audience and not just with the traditional trick of having a female creator on it, which is pretty much how they marketed Simone's Batgirl and Birds Of Prey before it. Babs Tarr's art is a big part of this: more akin to Lumberjanes or Girls With Slingshots than the traditional superhero house styles, swapping out the style that has historically alienated women for the styles of comics that have been more welcoming to them.

A comic's cover is not art alone, it is also a piece of advertising and good advertising is meant to send out a coherent, unified message. The purpose of this series from the writing to the art to most every other piece of marketing has been to foster a sense of Batgirl as embodying the traditional superhero power fantasy for young women divorced from many of the usual problems that plague female superheroes in that regard. To then pair this with a prominent image of Batgirl restrained and visibly terrified is a massively dissonant note that contradicts the central message of the series.

The cover image is disturbing in a way that does not suit the series it would have been used in and this, more than anything, is why I think it was a good decision for DC to pull the cover. Hell, of all series for this to happen to its strangely fitting for it to happen with the Cameron/Fletcher Batgirl, whose creators were previously criticised for the use of transphobic tropes in one issue. Their response, in an open letter, was to look at their work and apologise for the feelings it evoked, for not properly considering the issues when they wrote and drew those scenes and to thank their audience for provoking the discussion and expressing hope that they and others would be able to create better stories as a result of those discussions.

Especially given DC's own sidestepping of all responsibility in their corporate response to this issue, its nice to see that the DC title designed to appeal to women is also the comic whose contributors own their actions. 

Wednesday, 18 March 2015

Na-na-na-na-na-na-na-na Bat Power Armour

I think the thing I like the most about this image (apart from the return of the Morrison-era proto-Superman costume) is Clark's expression. “No... seriously, what the new costume like?” he seems to be asking, convinced Bruce has just spent a ton of cash on an elaborate wind-up and he ain't impressed. “Lois was coming over tonight and you said this was important!”

“But, look... rocket launcher.”

“Don't call me for a while, Bruce.”

On pure aesthetics... I don't know. I assume Bruce (or whoever) is all scrunched up in the main torso as no way would human shoulders stretch wide enough to fit the arms. The bunny ears are no more ridiculous than the traditional costume's bunny ears have been at times. Be interesting to see this new Batman inspecting crime scenes, not because I expect the suit to have a huge suite of CSI tech but just to see how he'll fit in the room.

Eh, we'll see how this works out for the inevitable year and a bit before the “proper” Batman is restored and if nothing else the post-Convergence solicits for Detective Comics promise me Renee Montoya so that'll soften the blow. 

Tuesday, 17 March 2015

Renegades & Heretics pt.1: special rules and the Warlord

I may have mentioned before my absolute infatuation with Forge World's Renegades & Heretics army list from Imperial Armour 13: War Machines Of The Lost And The Damned. I'm greatly enjoying my Orks even though I'm 0 for 2 so far and I anticipate a third defeat against Dave's Tau Empire in my first campaign game this weekend. Still, the Lost and the Damned are my signature army and IA13 cost me a pretty penny so its time to sort out what I want to do with this thing.

I was going to do a post for each slot (one for HQ, one for Elites, and so on) but the list is so aggressively complicated that the Warlord choice needs a post all to itself. There's a strange nostalgia here for the beloved Codex: Chaos Space Marines 3.5 edition, though there's nothing so obtuse here as hiding parts of actual rules in fiction box-outs.

Plus there are a few army special rules we should cover first:

Uncertain Worth (and how to game it)

Uncertain Worth (previously the Renegades rule) is one of my favourite mechanics ever. Most of the Renegades & Heretics units don't have a Leadership value. Instead, the first time you have to take a Leadership test you roll a D6 and add 4 for a result between 5 and 10 and that's the unit's Leadership for the rest of the game. I don't mind a little randomness in my game mechanics so I love it but I can certainly see why others might hate it with a fiery passion.

The rolled value can be altered, though, and that softens the blow. If you give the unit a vox-caster the result can be re-rolled (though I wouldn't do it for anything other than a roll of 1 or 2); you can give the unit a Chaos Sigil which allows them to ignore the first failed Morale Check or Pinning Test in each game turn; units with the Fanatic special rule roll 2D6 for Uncertain Worth and pick the highest; or you can add an Enforcer (a sort of Chaos Commissar) to the unit for +1 Leadership.

And so we move on to the knotty problem of determining who is going to lead this tide of heresy to glory...

Chaos Covenants

Mortals are too lowly to benefit from the actual Marks Of Chaos lbut they have their own version: Chaos Covenants. A lot of unit champions can be upgraded to have a Covenant and the effects carry over to their unit: Khornates get re-rolls to Wound in the first round of close combat; Nurglesques get Feel No Pain (6+); Slaaneshis get Fleet; and Tzeentchians take their Snap Shots at BS 2 (no, you can't give that to Heavy Weapons Squads, sorry).

The Arch-Demagogue and Renegade Command Squad

This is basically an Imperial Guard Company Command Squad with variable Leadership: instead of a Company Commander you have the Arch-Demagogue and instead of Veterans you have Disciples, the stats are the same. The unit has Fanatic and the capacity for a vox so, spectacular bad luck notwithstanding, you should get at least decent Leadership. The unit can be tooled up in all the usual ways: specials and heavy weapons, banners (one gives +1 combat resolution, another allows units within 12” to roll 3D6 for Morale and Pinning); carapace armour while the Demagogue has a choice of the usual special weapons and an invulnerable save upgrade.

That's all pretty standard issue kit but what makes it fun (and complicated, but mostly fun) are the many directions you can customise the Arch-Demagogue (who, I must admit, doesn't have to be your Warlord but if he isn't he can't benefit from anything that follows).

Chaos Covenants redux: Master of Renegades
The Demagogue can benefit from a Chaos Covenant but his opens up additional units (of course, you could go Unbound and take whatever you want but this way you stay Battle Forged).

A Covenant of Khorne gets you a unit of Blood Slaughterer walkers as Elites; a Covenant of Nurgle opens up Blight Drones (Elites) and Plague Zombies (Troops); Covenant of Slaanesh gives you Noise Marines and Sonic Dreadnoughts (both Elites and, frankly, a bit too transhuman for my tastes); Covenant of Tzeentch gets you Chaos Spawn (Elites); and taking no Covenant to represent the old Mark of Chaos Undivided unlocks Renegade Marauders, which in 40k are space pirates and mercenaries.

We'll get to Marauders in another post but between them and the fact I pine for the days when Chaos Undivided was a thing I'm definitely going with that option.

Demagogue Devotions

Customising opportunity number two is the Devotions system, in which you choose what sort of heretic your Arch-Demagogue is. You can only put a devotion on a single Demagogue and he must be your Warlord, which is a pity because there are a lot of great options here.

Primaris-Rogue Witch is the psyker option and the only way to get Malefic Daemonology into the army (yes, there is a psyker unit. No, they can't take Disciplines) as well as Biomancy, Pyromancy and Telekinesis. He can be Mastery Level 1 or 2, is Fearless and unlocks Rogue Psyker Covens as Elites as well as HQ.

Mutant Overlord is pretty self-explanatory concept-wise. He gets three rolls on a table that adjusts his stats, some up, some down and he might become Bulky and Slow And Purposeful. His Disciples get Curse Of Mutation which is another table to decide what their mutation is giving them Fear, Acute Senses or Hammer Of Wrath, each with its own disadvantages thrown in that make me question the worth of it all.

You also have to have two Mutant Rabbles as compulsory choices though you do get the choice of having a Chaos Spawn unit as a Troops choice without having to take a Tzeentchian Covenant, plus you Ogryns can upgrade to have Curse Of Mutation. All nice but too many drawbacks and things you have to have for my liking.

Heretek Magus is all about toughening up your army. The Magus himself has a 3+ armour save, +1 Toughness and Feel No Pain (6+). You can also upgrade a whole bunch of units, pretty much anything man-sized, to have Feel No Pain. Evene better you can have Defilers! Also Decimators but that's not such a big deal to me because I love Defilers!

Master Of The Horde gets a bunch of free troops... maybe. Every time a Renegade Infantry Squad that started off with 15 or more models flees off the board or is destroyed you roll a dice and on 5+ and reappears with all upgrades (not transports) intact. In exchange you have to have a minimum of two Renegade Infantry Platoons but the maximum unit size on Infantry Squads is raised to 30.

Bit chancey, really and though I'm a big believer in basic troops that's a lot of the same model to paint.

Arch-Heretic Revolutionary gets Zealot (pass all Leadership-based tests and re-rolls To Hit in the first round of combat) and gets his Chaos Covenant for free; you can give Renegade Infantry units Fanatic; and you can have 10 Enforcers to a choice instead of 5. Its a nice theme and probably one I'd be taking if not for...

Bloody-Handed Reaver, which is the Traitor General concession. My Lost And The Damned have always been a straight-up Guard army that happens to be from a Chaos culture (they are not traitors, I am quite insistent on this!) and here;s the perfect choice for me.

The Reaver himself gets krak grenades and a refractor field for free and he can upgrade to a hot-shot lasgun or laspistol. Better yet your Renegade Infantry Veteran Squads can upgrade hot-shot weapons (including volley guns) and BS4 to create Traitor Tempestus Scions (or Storm Troopers in the old money) which suits me down to the ground as I have some old characters that would be perfect for.

This Devotion also has a magnificent false drawback in that any unit that can take Militia Training (an upgrade that makes them as good as Guardsmen at shooting and fighting) must do so, and can also have flak armour. Again, suits me fine.