From
Adventures of Superman #504.
The over-designed guns, the crazy hair, the black, the ammo
bandoleers, the curious utility garters. I don't miss those days,
give me an issue of Willow-Wilson's Ms. Marvel
any day.
Thursday, 11 June 2015
Tuesday, 9 June 2015
I sort of want to watch Sailor Moon now...
A
few days ago it turned out my neighbor's kid had been leeching my
internet. She's eight and it turns out my wi-fi reaches her room. I
discovered this because my Youtube recommendations were suddenly
filled with Sailor Moon videos because she's big into Sailor Moon
right now.
And
I am a little curious. Anime is something I dip into every now and
again and, for probably obvious reasons, I've never watched Sailor
Moon but I get the idea its this huge thing in the anime world. Its
the magical girl anime,
admittedly the only one I know the name of but just that tells me it
has huge cultural cache.
I
vaguely remember being leant one of the books by a friend when I
was... twelve, maybe thirteen. It didn't really grab me but back then
I just couldn't read manga: I kept forgetting the right-to-left thing
and the book was really low quality like a bad photocopy. All I
remember is Tuxedo Mask because a) I like a good mysterious stranger
story and b) such a simple but cool design.
And
it would just be an interesting experience. I've dipped into a lot of
the big animes, loved some (Fairy Tail, One Piece), hated others
(Naruto) but all in the shounen “boys” manga vein. I've never
watched a magical girl anime, everything I know about the genre comes
from jokes in Megatokyo. It's a new art form to me and I actually
looking forward to exploring it a little.
Monday, 8 June 2015
Farewell, fair Bretonnia
Well,
not really. I still love the Bretonnia concept and the miniatures and
I'm absolutely reviving the army... just not using my old models. You
see, I'm one of those artistic
people: the ones who hate anything they did more than a few years ago
with a visceral passion. I painted these models when I was twenty. I
really couldn't paint that well and so I went for a “house”
colour scheme every knight had the same livery. Hell, if I could
actually paint then that might even have worked, I've seen some
fantastic Bretonnian armies painted that way.
A thing about me is that while I can and so repaint
models there comes a point where I've done it so many times to a
single model that I just can't do it anymore. Its a mental block that
is honestly cured by buying a new copy of the exact same model, which
is both irrational and financially ill-advised.
Still, my friend Tom wants a Bretonnia army of his own
and I want to get rid of this so I've been sorting it all out,
deciding what little I want to keep and the rest he can have for
whatever he feels is a fair price.
I'm keeping a few things: a Virtue Of Empathy Grail Lord
I converted (not well, but it has sentimental value); some spare
Grail and Questing Knights that I can add to my new Finecast ones to
create FULL LANCE FORMATIONS BWAHAHAHA!!!; and the fifth edition
Damsel On Foot, who is genuinely the best damsel model GW has ever
made. The rest can go and good riddance.
I really hope Tom enjoys them. He's got some damn funny
ideas about keeping the more exotic choices, like Grail Reliquaes and
Questing Knights, out of his army. I shall educate him. Once my own
Bretonnia army is built (I am a very slow painter and anyway my group
has no problem with in-progress minis going down on the table) I'll
take the field against his Empire, or even against his Bretonnians,
and show him the value of going to full monty with your spread of
knights.
Also, I have a Green Knight and he doesn't so we'll see
how he likes getting that to the face. I've never used the Green
Knight, I wonder if its still as sick as I heard it was back in the
day?
We shall see.
FOR HONOUR AND THE LADY! CHARGE!
Friday, 5 June 2015
Crappy "I have a cold" filler post
I
received a box set of Tomb Kings Carrion in my mail orders yesterday
and I had to get this joke out of my system:
Thursday, 4 June 2015
I wanted to review Fury Road but...
… but
the post just kept devolving into utter fanboy drooling about how
amazing Charlize Theron is as Imperator Furiosa so let's just embrace
that.
[minor
spoilers for Mad Max: Fury Road]
I
mean, just to start off with, its always nice to see Charlize Theron
being cast as something other than an imposing blonde sex goddess.
She's a great actress, a woman so good at projecting power (be it
physical, emotional or, yes, sexual) that its a crying shame that so
few directors seem to know what to do with her.
Hell,
she absolutely saved Snow White And The Huntsman as Ravenna,
the Evil Queen. That film was all kinds of confused about its tone
and what it wanted Kristen Stewart's Snow White to be but Theron just
about managed to rescue it. Up until now that was probably my
favourite role she's played but Furiosa blows Ravenna out of the
water.
For
a start she's very clearly not being cast for her looks here. Don't
get me wrong, there's not a make-up artist on the planet that can
make Theron unattractive but one of the benefits of the fact Furiosa
is smugglings sex slaves to freedom is that the slaves can be dressed
in floaty, diaphanous clothes and coded “attractive” so Theron in
her practical clothes and skin covered in layers of dirt gets to be
more clearly coded “fighter” and equal to, if not superior to,
Max in the narrative.
And
she absolutely is Max's equal if not narrative superior. This movie
is absolutely her story that
we are experiencing through the period in which it intersects with
Max's larger story. Max is the franchise, she is the film. This has
grated the spuds of a lot of... let's just call them sensitive
gentlemen who have a problem with this for some reason even though
this is a perfectly common way of handling a long-running character:
have them as a unifying presence in a bunch of stories about the
people they encounter. I've seen it done with Batman, Judge Dredd, a
few other long-running 2000AD strips and it is how Doctor Who has
worked since they started doing character arcs for companions. This
format basically allows there to be a defined journey with a
beginning, middle and end without spending all possible development
of the title character, or where all that possible development has
already taken place (like with Dredd).
Furiosa kicks arse, too. She has an amazing knock down,
drag out fist fight with Max early in the film and she's a dab hand
with firearms. She's absolutely a product of this world as much as
Max, Immortan Joe and the random gangs. Again, the presence of the
sex slaves allows fantastic contrast: they are beautiful and soft and
dressed to emphasise their femininity while Furiosa has very short
hair, very practical clothes, she's dirty, she's muscular, she's
armed. Her prosthetic arm matches the cobbled together over-design of
every other piece of technology in the film.
As for her personal journey that's too spoileriffic to
go into here but suffice to say that there's a fantastic consistency
in how her every action proceeds from a unified set of motivations
which are never explicitly explained but perfectly understandable
from those actions. More characters, not just female characters but
all characters in all media, should work like this.
Furiosa is a great character portrayed by a fantastic
actress and hopefully by tomorrow I'll be sufficiently over that fact
to actually discuss the film.
Tuesday, 2 June 2015
Big Finish Dr Who main range renewed to 2020
Yesterday,
Big Finish officially announced the continuation of their monthly
Doctor Who main range until the end of their current license in March
2020. This will bring them to their 262nd regular release.
That's an enormous amount of Doctor Who.
I
don't have the actual numbers to hand but between main range,
Companion Chronicles, Paul McGann and Tom Baker spin-offs and so on
there are already more Big Finish stories under the Doctor Who name
(nevermind Jago & Litefoot, Counter-Measures and the rest) than
have ever been made for TV. Every Doctor other than Tom Baker have
done more than twice as many Big Finish audios than they did TV
stories. Even Baker has enough stories on pre-order now that he will
have done more stories for BF than the BBC by the end of next year.
They've worked with every living regular actor from the classic
series bar one and she's never gonna do it so let's just call this as
big a win as they're getting.
They've
done wonders with the missed opportunities of the classic series:
producing stories that exploit Steven Taylor's backstory; finding a
way to make new stories with Sara Kingdom; completely rehabilitated
the Sixth Doctor (with no small amount of input from Colin Baker);
created a bunch of innovative new takes on the companion role; gave
us an actual Eighth Doctor era; and made several stories that deserve
a place on an “all time classics” list.
This
is not to say there aren't issues. In recent years their pool of
writers has shrunk somewhat with a lot
of stories coming out under the same names. Not bad names, not names
I dread or anything, give me a good Nicholas Briggs monster mash or a
John Dorney character study any day, but I do like a varied diet in
my Doctor Who. I'm also not totally convinced hour-long single CDs
were the best format for the Tom Baker range, they often feel rushed
and as if the stories don't have room to breath, oddly a feeling I
rarely had for the similar McGann line.
Still,
in spite of any of that this is my favourite form of Doctor Who right
now. I'm sort of fatigued on the TV show and the Doctor Who Magazine
comic strip never quite reaches the heights of its glory days (the
Eighth Doctor and 2009 Tenth Doctor strips, if you're wondering) and
the less said about the direction of the books the better.
So,
on balance I'm looking forward to this and I'm looking forward to
what these guys have coming up next.
Monday, 1 June 2015
Entertainment to do list
Saranga
had this idea a while ago, to write of all things a to do list of
things to watch and read. I'm in a mood to clear the decks rather and
I suppose this is as good a way as any. So what's on the slate?
Well,
for one thing, I need to watch The Keys Of Marinus
so I can get on with my Saturday Teatime watch through, so throw in
the rest of Season One (The
Aztecs, The
Sensorites and The
Reign Of Terror) into
the bargain. Also on the Doctor Who
front I've still not watched last year's series all the way through
yet, I only got as far as Robot
of Sherwood.
On
audio I have a couple of things I picked up in Big Finish sales and
on subscription to get through: four Dark Shadows plays
(The Death Mask,
The Voodoo Amulet,
Dress Me In The Dreams
and The Last Stop),
the Doctor Who: The Stageplays
trilogy and the first season of The Early Adventures.
I'll also end up with The First Doctor Companion Chronicles
volume 1 and The New
Adventures of Bernice Summerfield volume 2
sometime this month.
I've
had a few DVDs on loan from friends for far too long: the first two
seasons of The Walking Dead,
the classic mini-series Tripods
and The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel,
all of which should really go back to their owners at some point.
It
being one of my favourite series ever I should really watch the last
two “books” of Legend of Korra.
Also
in the spirit of catching up and concluding: the final episode of
Sherlock series
three, the final season of The Tudors,
the fifth season of Game Of Thrones
to date and Arrow,
which I have the first two season box sets of but haven't got past
episode six of the first.
I
really must pick up a copy of the Mad Max
trilogy and go see Fury Road
(not necessarily in that order).
Sunday, 31 May 2015
Hobby Projects: female Company Command Squad, Saurus Oldblood
Jute
Loyal Company Command Squad
I've
had a nice little break and its time to get back to it. For a start,
now I have both the Heroic Scale Female Heads from Statuesque
Miniatures and the Kilted Legs from Victoria Miniatures its high time
I made some of these female Imperial Guard I've been banging on about
for months. Hence:
Yes,
the officer is shorter than everyone else because my snips slipped
and I had to cut off the bottom of the torso. Sadly, this is the only
officer torso with boob-concealing flak armour so my officer gets to
be a bit on the short side. I like that, though, the image of this
stocky middle-aged woman in charge of a Guard regiment. I sort of
imagine her played by Miriam Margoyles or Sandy Toksvig.
I'm
leaning more towards Toksvig because of the no-nonsense voice.
One
Week Model Challenge
Saurus
Oldblood
Yeah,
my big mistake was trying to do whole units in a week so, from now
on, its going to be single models. This week: the Oldblood from the
Carnosaur kit, who is fantastic even if my shitty photography doesn't
show him off to best effect.
Friday, 15 May 2015
Reed Richards will bow before the might of Cameron!
I'm
not trying to turn this into a political blog. I'm not suited to that
sort of content as a person or a writer, plus it has this “shouting
into the wind” quality of futility given my traffic numbers, but...
… when
the Prime Minister makes public statements that can be seamlessly and
without editing pasted onto Doctor Doom (or Baron Greenback or Lord
Humungous or Calvin Candie or Skeletor, they've all been done, too)
its time to ask some very serious questions about where politics in
your country is going and whether you might not have spent five years
underestimating just how much crap the Lib Dem half of the coalition
was protecting us from.
Thursday, 14 May 2015
The Warhammer Armies Project
I
game with a pretty laid back group and I'm glad of that. There's been
at least one occasion when an old rule we assumed to still exist
turned out not to but it was too good to drop so we all came to a
gentlemen's agreement to let it stand (for the sake of clarity, the
rule was the one allowing Bretonnian Damels to sit in the middle of a
lance formation and use the unit's line of sight for casting).
So
having discovered Mathias Eliasson's Warhammer Armies Project I'm
relatively confident I could make use of one of his fan-made army
lists with the minimum fuss. He's so far written Army Books for
Albion, Amazons, Araby, a Bretonnia update and expansion, Cathay,
Chaos Dwarfs, the Cult of Ulric, Dogs of War, Estalia, Halflings,
Hobgoblins, the Kingdoms of Ind, Kislev, Nippon, the Norse and the
Pirates of Sartosa. All available for free as PDFs at the link above.
And
I am amazed by the production values on these things, they more than
match the official publications. I haven't read all of them but I
went straight to the Cathay book. There was a time when the original
Ogre Kingdoms book came out and it had so many references to the
Chaos Dwarfs and Cathay that we all assumed there was going to be a
push east and we'd see new armies springing up to represent places
and peoples missing from the game since second edition.
It
never happened and I've always wanted the option of a Cathay army or
an Araby army like the one in Warmaster (because elephant cavalry!).
Anyway,
I checked out the Cathay book and it seems pretty well-balanced. Just
about every unit has obvious strengths balanced by significant actual
weaknesses. Elite units have low armour, horde units have low weapon
skill and so on. Pretty standard but I've seen some horrendously
unbalanced fan lists in my day.
I
want to build a Gong. You can have a Gong in this army and its
useful. It acts as a sort of super-musician to the units around it.
It
would be a ton of conversion work but, to be honest, I think the
bodies of most units could be easily made using various elf kits
since a lot of those models use Asian influences. Low armour units
could easily be represented by strapping the right weapons to High
Elves Archers, high armour units by High Elves Spearmen and Wood
Elves Eternal Guard.
I
just have to somehow source or create appropriate some Han-style
heads and work out a kitbash for Cathayan longswords since all
existing human greatswords are very chunkily German.
I'm
trying to concentrate on the Lizardmen and the Orks but this is
damned attractive and it'd consciously be a very slow build. Damn it,
I'm convincing myself. Oh well.
Wednesday, 13 May 2015
Forever tempted towards White Scars
What
is it about White Scars that tempts me so? I mean, I know I can't
paint them as they have absolutely the most unforgiving colour scheme
ever invented. Yet there's an attraction to the idea because they're
very different from the (excuse the expression) standard template
Space Marine army.
And
they're absolutely one of my favourite ideas in Warhammer 40,000.
They are superhuman, power armoured Mongolian horse archers except
that since they're too large and heavy to ride a horse they ride
giant motorbikes instead! They don't fortify positions or hold
ground in any way, total freedom of movement is at the heart of how
they prosecute their wars. I love to settle my games in combat, I
find ranged fighting unsatisfying, so they're pretty much perfect for
me.
They
also don't make use of a load of things that have always been
mainstays of my Space Marine armies. They don't operate Devastator
Squads as they're far too static, using tanks Rhino-mounted Tactical
Squads for fire support. They don't use Dreadnoughts (and I bloody
love Dreadnoughts) because locking a White Scar inside a metal box,
forever disconnected from the feeling of the wind on his face, is
nothing short of a nightmare for them. They don't have Chaplains,
merging the role with their Librarians.
Chris
Wraight's excellent Horus Heresy novel Scars made me love this idea
even more since it presented their philosophy of war in these terms:
structures have weaknesses and will always fall once an enemy
identifies the location of that weakness. Constant movement
eliminates the existence of an identifiable centre, which the Khan
views as the ultimate weakness. In fact, Wraight has the Khan pretty
much predict the inevitability of something like the Horus Heresy
simply because the Imperium has centred its massive beaurocracy on
Terra.
There's
also a lovely throwaway line in which Malcador the Sigilite (aka
God's Best Mate) forgets the Khan when discussing the unaccounted-for
Primarchs and muses “That was
why he was created, after all.”. (He also has a line in which he
reflects that he told the Emperor to make the Primarchs daughters
instead of sons).
But.. painting white. I know I said I cracked it but
that much white is a whole other challenge. Ugh...
Tuesday, 12 May 2015
The disturbing moral implications of Pokemon
Last
night I couldn't get to sleep. Bored beyond words, too tired to do
anything but too awake to sleep, I grabbed my old Game Boy Advance
from the draws by my bed and decided to grind a few levels in Pokemon
Leaf Green until I finally nodded off. An hour later, somewhere on
Route 11 outside Vermillion City with the time approaching 2am in the
real world, I started to consider the morality of my actions.
I'm
not even talking about the fact Pokemon is basically a dogfighting
simulation with a fantasy anime coat of paint. I mean, that's
disturbing on its own if you choose to view things that way but it
goes deeper than that.
Here
I am (and by “I”, I mean the player character), a pre-teen girl
travelling without supervision through a heavily forested country
infested with dangerous animals. Why am I doing this? Because a
scientist who can't remember my name, my gender or the name of his
own grandson is too lazy to do his own research. Literally, that's
what the Pokedex mechanic is for in-story: to gather data on the
Pokemon you encounter on Professor Oak's behalf. And what was my
mother's reaction to all this? Approval. She's fine with it. She
knows girls want to travel.
That's
just the broad sweep of the story, when I consider my actions during
that short play session it gets even more disturbing, or at least it
did when the fatigue made me think too deeply about it.
In
the short hour I spent last night walking down Route 11 with the my
captive animals I went hunting in the long grass for wild animals to
victimise; attacked several electricians who were just going about
their business laying cables; was picked on in turn by numerous
shirtless old men; and practically mugged several children who were
using vastly lower level Pokemon than I was, netting myself over six
hundred dollars / yen / whatever of their money in the process. My
captive animals were continuously poisoned, knocked out, electrocuted
and concussed and when I returned to Vermillion City to have them
revived no questions were asked of me. Nurse Joy simply took them off
my hands, treated them and handed them back, no fuss whatsoever.
What's
more, in every battle I sent out my weakest Pokemon first, a Level 14
female Paras, who would get one pathetic attack in, get absolutely
walloped by the opposing Pokemon and then I'd replace her with
something that stood an actual chance. Why? Because just being in the
fight for one turn would mean she'd get an equal share of the XP and
level up to something approaching usefulness.
The
moral of the story? Take it as you will, either this is a good object
lesson in how academic education can make you read too much into
things or it shows that you should never take anything at face value
and critique everything. Both are true, in my opinion.
Monday, 11 May 2015
The Comics Ramble: Harley, is that you?
Oh,
I could rant about this image for hours. It'd be an easy post, a post
you've likely already seen elsewhere because I am slow as hell with
these things and we all know how it goes. I could point out how this
image started a forty-comment long Facebook conversation between
myself, three other comicbook geeks and an ICT teacher whose Google
Fu is worryingly good yet there were still two character we couldn't
identify. I could draw all the standard comparisons between the
DC-Warner and Marvel-Disney approaches. I could make all manner of
hyperbolic, nay histrionic, statements about how DC's obsession with
looking like adults does nothing of the sort.
But
I'm not gonna. I'm tired of being angry, about this and so many other
things, so I'm going to try and unpick something interesting (if
still highly critical) out of this image. You might remember when the
photo of the Leto Joker hit I said that when they released a
publicity shot of a halfway decent Harley Quinn then I would permit
myself to hope.
Well...
Now,
I don't want to use the phrase “slutty schoolgirl fantasy” out of
politeness... but I suspect the phrase probably came up in a design
meeting or two at Warner, is all I'm saying.
Harley's
been a lot of things over the years: a gangster's moll; an abuse
survivor carving out a life for herself; an arch-manipulator capable
of using everything from her education to her own mental condition to
twist others around her finger; an anarchic free spirit running an
apartment building for some very odd tenants... that's a lot of
different interpretations. I've seen her “be” a lot of different
characters in a lot of different media, so what is it about this
version that screams “Not Harley!” to me?
Hell,
I don't even mind the whole “Property of the Joker” line on the
back of her jacket. I mean, it does combine with the Joker's
“damaged” tattoo to make me wonder exactly how many show don't
tell violations this film will have (does Will Smith have “sniper”
written somewhere on his rifle, I wonder?) but when introducing
Harley to a whole new audience its probably important to start with
her in classic The Joker's Girlfriend mode and work up to the later
interpretations we comic fans all know and love.
(I'm
giving you credit here, Warner Bros., so please make her more than a
beaten woman and prove me right, okay? That shit's okay as a starting
point in the story, not as a whole character. Please don't make me
cringe through continuous scenes of abuse with no pay-off. Please
don't make me explain those scenes to the many co-workers who come to
me after every comicbook movie with trivia questions. Don't do that
to me. Thank you.)
No,
my essential problem with this costume is it looking nothing like a
harlequin. It actually seems to have escaped everyone's notice when
designing this thing that Harley's name is a pun. Even this
monstrosity...
… makes
reference to that fact in its use of colour. Even though its the
least Harlequin-esque of her costumes it conveys a few important
visual cues about her personality: the red and black are a bold
contrast, noticeable, its a performative costume that she wants to be
noticed; its more blatantly sexualised than her more usual look but
that still draws attention to her physicality and Harley is a very
physical character; the white skin (bleached in this version, usually
make-up in others) references her link to the Joker and serves to
make her stand out even further.
Movie
Harley has a bit of slap on her face, almost invisible given the
lighting of the picture, and we return to one of my initial problems
with the image as a whole: who are these guys? There's not much
visual information conveyed about these characters: some are clearly
soldiers, some are in civvies; there's a mummy hiding in the rear to
be as indistinct as possible; a relatively on-model version of a very
minor hero; there's Will Smith being all marketable; and our subject
for today: what appears to be a bad modernisation of Sandy from the
final act of Grease.
Yet
I can see what they're going for here once I scrape away my confusion
about who's who and look at this as marketing. Let's just take the
bull by the horns and compare this cast to the Avengers: there are
more women on this team and its more ethnically diverse even than the
post-Age Of Ultron Avengers. That message just gets drowned out
because so few of the characters have good visual identifiers and its
the geek media who are meant to share this around and go “Look!
Look which characters they're doing!”.
And
yet here I am confident the woman in the middle is Harley Quinn only
because she's the blonde. There should be more to work with than
that.
Sunday, 10 May 2015
Weekly War Diary #3: Build-A-Lizard week
Given
the run-up to the election and the slump of ennui that followed I got
little done this week. Still, something happened yesterday that made
me want to jump back into my hobby head-first: I went round a
friend's house and watched some games.
My
gaming group has mainly been playing 40k since February for Dave's
map campaign but yesterday some of us got together and had some games
of Fantasy. I didn't even play, I was shattered from work and was on
rulebook duty (which, by the way, is not only a great way for someone
not playing to feel useful but really helps prevent rules-flicking
from disrupting the flow of the game).
We
actually got three small games done that afternoon: Matt's Orcs &
Goblins vs Tom's Empire; Tom's Empire vs Iain's Chaos Warriors; and
Iain's Warriors vs. Tom's Empire. Wins: Orcs & Goblins; Warriors;
Empire.
It
was fun. God, we were rusty, though and the rulebook got a good
workout.
Anyway,
I've got a week off and not many plans since no one's around during
the day. I want to play Fantasy and I feel the Vampire Counts have
run their course so I want the Lizardmen up and running. Working from
the army list I posted up a week or so back I've already got the 12
Skink Skirmishers and the plastic Skink Priest done plus the other
Priest and the Kroxigor from the box of stuff Matt gave me.
Plus
it'll give me something to do with my hands while I catch up with
some audios.
Saturday, 9 May 2015
Japanese War Tubas
They
existed. Here's photographic evidence. They were an acoustic,
pre-radar form of aircraft detection. The operator wore earphones
attached to the giant tuba horn.
Yeah,
I'm just not up to anything more complicated than this today.
Friday, 8 May 2015
An open plea to Conservative voters
Given
that the next five years are not going to be fun for me, can I just
ask this one thing? Just one thing and it won't take you long?
Take
your copy of the Conservative manifesto (and if you don't have one,
please download it and consider carefully why you didn't have one but
voted this way regardless) and take note of the policies and promises
that led you to vote the way you did. Keep the notes, keep the
manifesto and every now and again read them over again and check to
see whether the promises and policies you voted for have been
delivered on.
This
isn't even me saying the Conservatives will naturally ignore their
manifesto promises: I was planning to post this regardless of who
won. It would be up here as “An open plea to Labour voters” if
things had swung that way or an “An open please to Liberal Democrat
voters” if we lived in a wildly different alternate universe, just
with a different opening paragraph.
I'm
not even saying that if you find a single promise undelivered on
that's a huge betrayal. Things change and needs evolve, just take a
cold and cynical look at it if it happens. If more people took time
to actively track the delivery of manifesto promises we might see the
Number 10 changing hands a lot more often than we do.
General Election 2015
So,
I was wrong. As I write this with 620 seats declared the
Conservatives are on the way to an overall majority or to being a
minority government so close to true majority it doesn't make a
difference.
I've
made no secret that I really hoped the days of majority government
were over. Coalition governments are actually quite common in the
rest of Europe and I was hoping that the necessity of actively
involving more minority parties at the policy level would soften the
neoliberal tendencies that all three major parties display to one
horrifying degree or other.
Well,
two major parties now since the Liberal Democrats have only won eight
seats when they previously held fifty-seven. I don't know how I feel
about that. I understand why it happened but the numbers tell an odd
story, at least to me. Labour have lost seats unless they sweep the
board in the remaining forty constituencies so the logical conclusion
is that LibDem voters, frustrated at their party spending five years
as an extension of the Conservatives, have voted Conservative.
I
just don't understand people. This is my third General Election and
I've never seen people more politically engaged. I've never seen
minority parties make gains in public recognition that would have
been unthinkable even ten years ago thanks to social media and other
resources relieving the strangehold the tabloids had on our political
understanding (and, seriously, look at some of the blatant attacks on
the front pages the last few days). I've never seen people looking
into minority parties as a legitimate wayto exercise their franchise
instead of as an impotent “protest vote”.
Yet
after five years of austerity measures that haven't worked; after
numerous attacks on public services; after years of rhetoric
attacking the poor and unemployed during a recession; and with the
chance of a new coalition giving value to voting for a minority party
for the first time in my generation's lifetime...
… a
massive vote of confidence in the status quo.
Seems
Gordon Brown was wrong: the Scots didn't need to vote SNP to get a
Tory government, its happening anyway.
I
know this is just the gloom talking but the only hope in my life
right now is that South Thanet hasn't been called at this time and we
might yet be rid of the Testicle-Faced Hobgoblin.
Thursday, 7 May 2015
Creators and the Progressive Pedestal
The
Joss Whedon thing is still young but there are a few things I want to
tease out of it because I think they have value in a broader context.
As I said yesterday I don't want to dive too far into the specific
scene that started all this because I've only seen it once whilst
half-distracted by people around me texting, eating and being
generally annoying. No, I want to discuss some more peripheral
aspects of this whole thing, first of all the tendency we have to put
creators on an unsustainable pedestal.
Let's
get some distance from Whedon first because emotions there are
running hot and that's never useful to a conversation. One of my
favourite webcomics is Go Get A Roomie by Belgian writer-artist Chloe
C. One of the most notable aspects of the series is the amazing
diversity of its cast which features a surprising variety of sexual
and gender identities, each explored in interesting and considered
ways. There's even a character (currently) portrayed as asexual and,
let me tell you, as someone who identified as asexual for years it is
refreshing not only to see that identity portrayed but portrayed with
a clear understanding that there's nothing socially or medically
wrong with the character. Once the context of her sexuality is
understood by the other characters its accepted and any “pushing of
boundaries” is either done by her own agency or in reference to the
still open question of whether she's aromantic.
(I'm
summarising hugely here, by the way, and the character may turn out
not to be as asexual as she currently seems but, hey, I'm intimately
aware that sexual identity can change so yet again we're in “Yay!
Representation!” territory as far as I'm concerned. Seriously, read
this comic, its cool.).
Okay,
so apart from a two paragraph fanboy plug how does this relate to our
subject today? Well, because Chloe C. has several times addressed
concern about how people put her on a pedestal when it comes to queer
issues. It isn't hard to see why people are inclined to do this,
she's a fantastic author and I've learnt things as a direct
consequence of her work so I definitely see why its happened. For the
record she's expressed her discomfort with the pedestal both on her
Tumblr where she's cautioned people that any advice she gives on
these issues should not be taken as a definitive statement and in the
strip itself through the title character Roomie having insecurities
surrounding other idolising her.
(Tumblr,
by the way, is probably the worst blogging system that exists for
when you want to quote something: posts don't have titles and the
archive system uses this not all that useful thumbnail method and
though I can't find the post I want to quote, this Ask one pretty
much sums up the whole shebang).
So
what's wrong with the pedestal? Well, its unsustainable, frankly.
People screw up. Everyone. You, me, Chloe C., Whedon, the lot of us.
There's no amount of editing or self-critique that's going to stop
someone someday putting out something that will play poorly to
someone out there, maybe to a lot of someones. To use another
example, one of the braver creative acts I've seen on the internet
was when Jeph Jacques, writer-artist of Questionable Content,
revealed one of his characters to be trans and openly said in a news
post:
“I
have to admit, I am nervous about posting this comic, because
including a trans person in my cast is something I have wanted to do
for years and I really, really want to do a good job of it. One of
the major themes of QC, I think, is of inclusion, and this seemed
like a pretty important thing to include. I have given it a lot of
thought and done a lot of research, so hopefully I won't screw up.
I'll do my best, anyway.”
This
brings us to a second issue I want to bring up, a sentiment that I've
seen in a few quarters and that I'm going to paraphrase because I
don't want to look like I'm calling anyone particular out. This has
been expressed in a lot of different ways and to a lot of different
degrees but the basic sentiment is this:
“If
Joss Whedon can't write good female characters he shouldn't bother.”
Sidestepping
the question of what “good” even means in this context because I
could write a dozen posts on that alone, the idea that a perfect
portrayal is the only one that can be worthwhile is intensely
problematic. Jacques introduced a trans character and expressed his
concerns that he might not be able to do the idea justice and in
other places he's solicited criticism to help him improve that
portrayal. In an ideal world criticism is about a social
conversation, not necessarily involving the creator under critique
but that's a nice bonus if you can get it, about how art can be
improved. Just yelling “Stop!” when something isn't perfect
defeats the whole point because how does anything ever improve under
those conditions?
Also,
why would anyone create under those conditions? There's no incentive
to take risks there. All the creatives I've mentioned in this post
have one thing in common: they're progressives (or liberals or social
justice types or however you want to express it). Jacques and Chloe
C. identify inclusivity as a central tenet of their art and Whedon
came to prominence through creating Buffy The Vampire Slayer which is
perhaps most notable for its female and queer characters.
As
a not unnatural consequence the fans of these peoples' work are also
generally progressives because people tend to latch on to things they
agree with. In the dim mists of long ago when I started writing this
post I mentioned how I identified with the sexual identity of one of
Chloe C.'s characters and that's a big part of why she became a
creator I took an active interest in to the point of, say, reading
her tumblr and looking up her Deviantart page instead of just
reading that one project of hers.
And
because progressives are interested in progress (not, y'know,
unnaturally) when one of these creators takes a retrograde step,
intentional or not, it can make the progressive fan very angry.
Progressives are usually politically engaged and by the nature of
that we're often politically enraged in what feels like an
increasingly conservative culture. So when one of our heroes, one of
the people we've emotionally invested in for agreeing with us when so
much mass media doesn't, makes a mistake we can take it as a very
personal betrayal.
We're
not unjustified in feeling let down, I'm not suggesting anyone gets a
free pass here. Criticism is an important force that should be
applied to all art as a matter of course. Its just that I think we
would all (creators, critics and consumers alike) be better served by
remembering that no one and nothing is perfect and never will be.
Mistakes should be brought up and discussed but by no means should
they be reason to disregard all work of the author, let alone future
work that could be improved by a reasoned conversation about those
mistakes the creative could learn from.
Labels:
criticism,
internet controversies,
the internet,
theory
On voting, not voting and coalitions
Its
election day and there's been a lot of discussion the last few months
about whether not voting is a valid act or protest. I am voting, as
it happens, but I wanted to say this:
If
you aren't voting because you can't find a political party whose
policies you believe in then I totally respect that. Voting is
ultimately an act of conscience and it would be morally wrong of me
to encourage someone to vote for something they don't believe in.
If
you don't feel any connection to politics then I'd ask you to
reconsider but I wouldn't blame you. I'd blame the political culture
for forcing that disengagement through decades of betraying the
common trust.
I
do believe there's some worth in voting and I do have a party whose
principles I've come to believe in. I actually have missed a couple
of elections, mainly local ones, in my younger years but over the
last six or seven years I've become much more politically engaged. It
is an uphill struggle, though, given that so much news media biases
to the right (it really does, no matter what the right says because
deference to power equals access to power so most media tends to
defer to those in power) and there's an increasing amount of fact
checking you have to do to take anything a politician says as truth.
I'm
not one to predict how these things go but I do think we'll have
another coalition because the rise of minor parties the last few
years (for good or ill) means we aren't facing a world of two horse
races anymore. In a way this makes voting more important as the
composition of government is going to be more complex than simply
achieving a parliamentary majority. A small increase in the number
of, say, Green or SNP members in a theoretical coalition would have a
real effect on policy.
You
see how this could be better than a majority party? Voting for
smaller parties who could never form a majority becomes more
valuable. There could never be a Green or SNP government, under
majority rule they'd always be on the opposition side of the house,
at least in any immediate term. Now, if one of those parties gained a
significant block of the members and a coalition was needed they'd
have a genuine chance to affect policy from within the ruling party
instead of simply voting for or against when presented with an
already written proposition.
If
you agree more with Green or SNP policies you can vote for them with
a chance they'll be in government even if they aren't the ruling
party, its actually quite exciting.
Wednesday, 6 May 2015
Extra History and the GOOD side of the internet
The
internet is a shitty, shitty place at times. Just this week
controversy over a character beat in Avengers: Age Of Ultron somehow
snowballed over social media into Joss Whedon receiving death threats
and shutting down his Twitter account. That controversy is certainly
worth discussing because that discussion could take in a lot of
larger issues of female representation in film and also works as a
good case study in why we shouldn't put creators on a political
pedestal that they'll inevitably fall from because they're human and
unable to consider every
socio-political angle of their work.
But,
of course, this is the internet and so a section of this debate gave
in to the human tendency towards extremism and starting screaming
threats. This, however, is a discussion for another day, in my case
preferably a day when Whedon has released more details about what was
said to him and when I've viewed the scene in question more than
once.
Today
I want to cheer myself up by talking about something good on the
internet, something educational that gives me faith that the average
person on the net isn't just there to make themselves feel big by
screaming their views at the top of their capslocks with zero
critical thought applied to themselves.
I
want to talk about a little Youtube series called Extra History.
I've
written in the past that I believe strongly in populist history. Not
dumbed down history, not inaccurate history (though small
inaccuracies are sometimes a necessary evil which we'll get to later)
but presenting history in an accessible way.
I
love history but the history I love isn't the history I was ever
taught at school. History at school was very dry, a list of facts
that create a very clean and ordered narrative leading from A to B
to, about 70% of the time, a World War. The other 30% of the time we
were doing the later Tudor monarchs. We didn't get much context
outside of the big facts we'd need to know for the exam.
So
that's why I love populist history series like The Mark Steel
Lectures and the series we're talking today: Extra History.
Let's
take one of the subjects I allegedly “learnt” about at school:
the outbreak of the First World War. As far as my teachers and,
sadly, I was concerned
how it went was Arch-Duke Franz Ferdinand was shot in a way presented
as a sort of dress rehearsal for Dallas 1963 and a few weeks later
the war began. We were given no context, no details of the politics
that led to the assassination. All we were told, all we were judged
to need, was that Ferdinand's death was categorically the spark that
ignited the war. I don't even think it was a whole lesson.
A
couple days ago Youtube threw Extra History at me in my
recommendations and they had a series of five videos called World War
I: The Seminal Tragedy. Two things were important about these videos.
The first was that it covered the assassination of Ferdinand and the
other events leading into the Great War in greater detail than I'd
ever heard. They presented the story as grand tragedy, which it
obviously is but which school failed to fully clue me in on. The
players are presented briefly but concisely and I was startled by the
fact that several attempts to kill Ferdinand that day failed and how
he eventually died only through a startling coincidence.
The
second thing that was good about the series was the final video,
subtitled simply “Lies” in which the series writer James Portnow
corrects some artistic mistakes (anachronistic flags), common
mistakes he made (saying “Moscow” instead of “St. Petersburg”
in reference to the Russian capital of the day), confessing that some
incidents in the video were based on common readings of events rather
than absolute facts and offering some extra context that couldn't fit
in the previous episodes due to time considerations. Portnow gains
great respect from me for then saying “don't trust us […] don't
trust any one source”, which is one of the most important things to
learnt about history.
I
actually took the fact about Britain's national debt in yesterday's
post from the Extra History series on the South Sea Bubble, something
I'd heard the name of but had absolutely no idea what it was even
though it continues to affect our country's economy. I did make sure
to do a little reading before citing it and, though some details were
glossed over in the video, the fact was sound enough to use as the
basis of a post.
I
guess this brings us to the “necessary evil” of small
inaccuracies, which Portnow admits to in that one episode. First off
these videos are made by a staff of three people and he's the sole
writer so there are going to be things he misses. Second is, as he
says, its good practice to check you've been told the truth or if
there are other interpretations, which the day before a general
election I think is a lesson worth teaching for a lot of other
aspects of our lives.
But
why does this restore a little of my faith in humanity after the
Whedon thing? Because Extra History started off as a marketing thing:
a series on the Punic Wars paid for by the makers of Rome: Total War
but now its paid for, and the subjects voted for, by Extra Credits'
Patreon backers. Those backers voted for the South Sea Bubble over
the campaigns of Julius Ceasar. They chose
an obscure event over one they would have known to be flashy and
exciting. Its a decision that was considered and driven in the
majority of cases by a genuine desire to be educated. That version of
the internet, a tool for education used by people who want to be
educated, is one I wish I had more examples to crow about.
[Extra
History is hosted on the Extra Credits Youtube channel here.]
Tuesday, 5 May 2015
A quick note about national debts
One
of the issues that has been doing the rounds in the run up to
Thursday's general election is the matter of our national debt. This
is apparently very, very important if you listen to how the
Conservatives are building it up.
The
thing is that as important as national debt it and that it affects
the cost of things and all sorts of other bits of economics, paying
it off isn't as important in the immediate term as is being
advertised. Let me give two examples of debts owed by the government.
First
there's Lend-Lease, a loan agreed in 1941 to supply war materiel made
in the United States to us, the Free French, China and later other
allies. The basic sense of it was we got our planes and tanks for
free in the short term and paid off the debt after the war. The UK
paid of its share of Lend-Lease in 2006.
What's
more, three months ago George Osborne signed off on a payment to
settle part of a debt the
government has been paying off since 1710.
As
I said at the top of this post: national debt is an important issue
with a lot of effects but don't be fooled into thinking its going to
bankrupt the nation any time soon. These things are calculated to be
paid off in terms longer (sometimes far longer) than a human
lifetime.
And
people wonder why I do so much reading around political issues
instead of just listening to what politicians say on television.
Monday, 4 May 2015
Torchwood, eh?
Big
Finish have announced the second of their “New Series” projects
and its... well, probably the most obvious and somehow the oddest of
choices: Torchwood.
On
the one hand its not hard to see why: the Torchwood TV series has
ground to a halt after its fourth season and there have been several
Torchwood radio plays in the past.
So
why am I surprised? Well, to be honest, because of a rather unpopular
opinion of mine: I don't think Torchwood ever really worked. Of its
four seasons the only one I'll go to bat for and say was all that
good was the second. The first season was all sorts of insecure,
working out a bunch of anxieties about being the BBC's first “adult”
post-watershed sci-fi by doing the obligatory sex alien episode and
having everyone shag everyone else at some point in the show. The
second season largely got over those jitters, settled on a tone and
got on with things but then the series started haemorrhaging cast
members at a rate of knots. Then came the mini-series era with
Children Of Earth and Miracle Day, neither of which really came
together for me.
Maybe
its just me, of course, and I can't claim that Big Finish haven't
taken worse ideas and made them work. There was one good season,
after all, and John Barrowman is always a delight as Captain Jack.
And
maybe we'll finally find out what happened in those three yeas he
can't remember from back when he was a Time Agent that was alluded to
waaaaaaaay back in The Empty Child. I'm reasonably sure that never
got resolved in either TV show. This is the company that made me like
Mel Bush and turned Steven Taylor into something other than a
plot-convenient cipher.
Time
will tell, it usually does.
Sunday, 3 May 2015
Weekly War Diary #2: Complete Lack Of Progress Report
Well,
not actually zero progress but nothing really worth commenting on. I ended up
painting the Skinks in a very, very crap way before breaking,
paint-stripping the lot and investing in a copy of How To Paint
Citadel Miniatures: Lizardmen.
I
have to say that I like these ebook How To Paint guides a lot more
than the paper ones. The stage-by-stage images are a lot easier to
follow when you can press the “next” button and the image changes
before your very eyes. In the paper version its more like a comic
strip and sometimes the subtler effects can be a bit hard to
distinguish, especially since layering is used to describe about five
separate techniques.
Anyway,
the purchase is paying off. Although the guide seems convinced the
Citadel Spray Gun was a good idea it didn't take me long to work out
what base paints to use since my spray gun went in the bin months
ago.
One
Week Hobby Challenge
Okay,
so my second attempt to complete a unit in a week resulted in a
second failure so let's streamline this down a bit. Its 40k's turn on
the Challenge so I'm going to paint my copy of Kaptin Badrukk, aka my
Ork Warlord Kaptin Thunderguts Snarla.
Saturday, 2 May 2015
Fox, please just give up on the Fantastic Four
So
apparently Fox have announced that in their new (hate-boner
commissioned) Fantastic Four movie Reed Richards will not have
stretchy powers. Instead he will warp time and space around his
limbs.
THERE
IS NO MIDDLE FINGER BIG ENOUGH!
And
no, this is not about “respect for the source material” or some
fannish nonsense like that. I don't mind changes to the source
material that do something to improve the plot. Take, for instance,
making Drax an alien in Guardians Of The Galaxy instead of an altered
human: that was a good idea because Star-Lord being completely
disconnected from any human contact was important to the plot.
This,
though? This is a change that will likely do literally nothing. His
power is still making his limbs longer its just instead of being made
out of rubber flesh he'll be manipulating time and space. Why?
Because it's less silly and apparently Fox is one of those companies
making comicbook movies that still cares about looking like adults.
I
watched Avengers: Age Of Ultron on Thursday and they showed the
Fantastic Four trailer beforehand. It was painfully generic, said
nothing, showcased none of the supposed changes to the story besides
Johnny being black and that science lab scene that makes it seem
oddly likely the FF's powers will be induced intentionally instead of
being a tragic accident. You know what, though? I can kind of dig
that just this once. Yes, it ignores the central tragedy that all the
pop art insanity of the FF is built on but since a) they screwed that
up good and proper last time and b) I really, really doubt this thing
will get a sequel, it might be interesting as a one off thing.
That
still doesn't solve what seem to be the central problems here: this
is a movie Fox doesn't want to make; has previously failed to make
work to the point of cancelling the series on a cliffhanger; and has
only commissioned so the rights won't revert to Marvel Studios and no
one has to explain to their bosses how Marvel made hundreds of
millions on an idea they couldn't score a profit on.
Its
just dumb. Really dumb. Time and effort is being wasted here for no
reason other than spite. Millions of dollars, too, on a film
rebooting a series that couldn't make a good enough profit even when
it largely prototyped the astronomically successful method Marvel
Studios uses on all its films.
I'm
serious. More with the first one than the second but Fox's last
Fantastic Four efforts gave them pretty faithful costumes and aside
from Doom they all had their established personalities and
interpersonal dynamics intact. What alterations were made were either
in service of streamlining the origin story or pointless alterations
to Doom's personality to reference the actor's role in Nip/Tuck. Hey,
I didn't say it was all good.
Yet
now they seem to be going with the dark and gritty treatment that has
gone so well for DC-Warner because this is just how insecurity
manifests in the production of superhero movies.
Friday, 1 May 2015
Summer Project 2015 army list
To
start the month off right here's the army list for my Summer Project,
a good chunk of which I want to get done over the course of May. Just
a little something to work to, at least to start with, based on the
following considerations: (1) what's in the Battalion I already own;
(2) what's in the box of miscellaneous stuff Matt sold me; and (3)
what looks pretty and I want to paint.
Lords
Saurus
Oldblood armed with hand weapon and shield, wearing light armour and
the Talisman of Preservation. 205pts
Heroes
Skink
Chief armed with hand weapon and shield, wearing light armour. 44pts
Skink
Priest, Level 2 Wizard using the Lore of Heavens. 100pts
Skink
Priest, Level 1 Wizard with the Lore of Beasts. 65pts
Core
20
Saurus Warriors armed with spears and shields, full command. 250pts
24
Skink Cohort armed with hand weapons, Lustrian javelins and shields,
2 Kroxigor and Skink Brave. 230pts
12
Skink Skirmishers armed with hand weapons and blowpipes, Patrol
Leader. 94pts
Special
Bastiladon
with Solar Engine and 3 Skink crew. 150 pts
5
Cold One Riders armed with spears and shields, full command. 200pts
1
Stegadon and 5 Skink crew armed with hand weapons, Lustrian javelins
and giant bow, Sharpened Horns. 235pts
20
Temple Guard armed with halberds and shields wearing light armour,
full command. 310pts
3
Terradon Riders armed with hand weapons, Lustrian javelins and rocks,
Sky Leader. 115pts
Total:
1998 points
I
think this just about covers all the bases: three rank-and-file
infantry units; two fast units; a combat-oriented general; some
magical support; a Skink Chief because nothing else would fit in the
points; and, most important of all, plenty of the big dinosaurs
centrepiece models. What's even better is the Battalion is a huge
chunk of it so there's not much more financial outlay to be had
(until I inevitably want to expand, of course).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









